Covid Passports: Fear of creeping authoritarianism

April 17, 2021

Over the week there has been a great deal of nervous debate about the rights and wrongs of Covid passports, which would provide certification of a recent negative test result, vaccination or the presence of antibodies. Unfortunately, there has been a bewildering over-simplification of what is a multi-faceted and complex debate.  Many of those arguing a particular case tend to use emotionally charged soundbites rather than a balanced and  thoughtful appraisal.

So far, 70 MPs  (40 Tories, 20 Labour and 10 LibDems) have stated outright opposition to Covid passports. Politicians who couldn’t normally agree on the day of the week are now basking in unabashed harmony on this issue. However, according to a YouGov poll this week, 58% of the public support the introduction of Covid passports. Evidence from a range of surveys suggests that people are more favourable of their use for optional activities rather than those that are integral to everyday life, and for people who work with the most vulnerable.

The irony is that both sides of the debate have frequently used very similar arguments to justify their perspectives. Whilst some have argued that the introduction of Covid passports will place obstacles in the path of endeavours to open up the economy, others believe precisely the opposite arguing that passports could help reopen sports, leisure, arts, and hospitality venues. 

Shami Chakrabarti argues that passports will permanently isolate people who won’t or can’t accept the vaccine thus creating a medical apartheid. Others believe that without passports, the reverse will happen with people anxious about becoming infected, even those who have had the vaccine, continuing to protect themselves by simply withdrawing into a permanent hermitage.  

Those in favour pose questions like, wouldn’t you prefer to go to a restaurant, cinema or pub where a Covid free environment is almost guaranteed? Wouldn’t you want proof that the care workers and NHS professionals taking care of your ageing and vulnerable parents have had the vaccine? If a Covid passport means that zero-Covid is brought within reach, and also limits the scope for dangerous mutations, wouldn’t you support it? Could Trade Unions come to the conclusion that the guarantee of a Covid-free workplace is a fundamental Health & Safety issue? The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) has received over 134,000 complaints since the crisis started, but issued only 192 enforcement notices. If the ‘science’ tells us that Covid passports will help us reduce risk to an absolute minimum, should we not be following the science?  However, there are wider issues to consider!

Despite the apparent benefits, it is unsurprising that those against Covid passports are most worried about the creeping authoritarianism of a Tory government that is currently attempting to impose disproportionate controls on free expression and the right to protest with the introduction of their ‘Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill’ which, to many, will force the police into acting as a politicised enforcement wing of government. Is it any wonder that this legislation, coupled with the potential introduction of ‘passports’, gives rise to suspicions of a Tory strategy to curtail freedoms, limit civil liberties, undermine fundamental human rights and increase ‘Big Brother’ surveillance?

There is a clearly justifiable fear that Covid passports could lay the foundation for an oppressive digital ID system which could normalise identity checks and put sensitive medical records in the hands of authorities and employers. To make matters worse, we have a Prime Minister who isn’t even trusted by his own side!

We are also right to be concerned about the motives of those hard right Tory fundamentalists whose dog-whistle rhetoric and polarising populism is imbued with duplicitous contradictions. For example, the hardline Tory MPs who belong to the lockdown-sceptic ‘Covid Recovery Group’(CRG) are against Covid passports but are fervently supportive of their Government’s dangerously oppressive legislative proposals. Though this may initially seem like a puzzling inconsistency, the CRG’s over-riding motivation is not about protecting civil liberties but more to do with fully opening the economy even if this means undermining the fight against Covid.

Of course, the issue of Covid passports would have been an irrelevance if the Government had been competent in their handling of the pandemic and hadn’t squandered a £37 million budget on crony contracts that continue to fail to deliver an effective test, trace and track system. The newly proposed twice a week lateral flow testing — which, incidentally, has shown to be up to 50% unreliable —  will achieve absolutely nothing without a fully functioning track, trace and isolate strategy. The Office for National Statistics report that 53% of people tested show a strong Covid infection, or high viral load, yet did not report any symptoms which underlines the risk of people unknowingly spreading the virus.

Despite the irresistible arguments against, it seems inevitable that there will be, at least, a ‘limited’ introduction of Covid passports. We must therefore focus our attention on how, when, where and how frequently they will be used. If introduced, they must be used strategically as defined by the science and operated securely within restricted and time-limited processes. Most crucially, they must come with all the safeguards necessary to protect our civil liberties, privacy and freedoms whilst avoiding negative discrimination and an increase in inequalities.

Dave Knaggs (Chair of Penrith & the Border CLP, written in  personal capacity) First Published in The Cumberland & Westmoreland Herald

Thank you

Why not have a look around the rest of the site while you are here?

Frequently Asked Questions

Why should I join Northern England Labour Left (NELL)?

NELL is about action. It is about doing something positive at a time when many Left activists are feeling demoralised and traumatised by the changes wrought by a bruising General Election, a new Leadership and other recent Party structural changes. Instead of leaving the Party NELL aims to give people hope and a positive vision for the future of Socialist politics in the North, as well as the skills and knowledge to be candidates, or to support them, for elected positions.

How is NELL different from Momentum, LLA, CLPD, CLGA, Don’t Leave,Organise etc.?

You can be members of NELL and members of Momentum etc. NELL is complementary and will work closely with these other organisations to ensure we are united in backing Left Socialist candidates for elected positions in the Labour Party and public office.

NELL is not a political talking shop. Our members actively work towards electing Left Socialist candidates for positions of power and influence at all levels across the Northern Region.

What part do members play in NELL’s democratic and organisational structures?

All full members can raise motions and vote at regular ordinary meetings and the annual general meeting. All members are involved in important decisions affecting how NELL operates, including electing NELL officers. All votes are One Member One Vote.

Operationally there is a Membership Services Group of volunteers who manage all aspects of membership, training and internal member communications, plus a separate Communications and Social Media Group responsible for external communications.

There is also an Organising Group which coordinates election support, affiliations, regional NELL groups and diversity and equality networks, as well as relationships with Labour affiliated unions and socialist societies. 

A Coordination and Support Team includes the four elected officers i.e. two Co-Chairs, Secretary, Treasurer and a Membership Secretary, plus other members as required for administration and support.

The Strategy Implementation Group, consists of representatives from all of the above operational groups. This group is at least 50% women and includes at least one each of BAME, LGBT+, Young member and Disabled Members representatives.

Why do I need a proposer and seconder on the application form?

Ensuring that members share our Aims, Values and Political Priorities and are willing to be active, is crucial to building NELL. We also want our members to know they belong to a trusted network of comrades who will not share confidential, strategic information outside the group. We ask for two ‘referees’ to ensure that people joining NELL meet these criteria, understand what we are about and are willing to engage and actively support the activities of NELL.

Why do I need to pay membership subscription fees and what will the money be spent on?

NELL has no staff and is entirely run by a number of hard-working volunteers. We have to support a Membership system and other IT for website, finance etc. but the bulk of our income will be spent on organising training, mentoring and political events and supporting working class Socialist candidates and under-represented groups to get elected. We also aim to support NELL members in attending Regional Conference if CLPs are unable or unwilling to help.

No one who wants to join NELL should be deterred by membership subscription costs. Please select the most affordable option for your personal circumstances.

There are four levels of NELL membership subscription available:

FREE for Young Members (under 27) and those under financial stress

CONCESSION rate of £1 a month or £12 per year for unwaged or low-income

BASIC rate of £3 a month or £36 a year for waged over 27, who can afford to pay this higher rate

SOLIDARITY rate starting from £4 a month or £48 a year up to as much as a member is willing and able to pay.

Can I be a supporter without joining NELL?

We are looking at introducing a Supporter category for those people who need time to consider if NELL is right for them, or for those who would otherwise be eligible but live outside the Labour North Region.

We hope to have this set up very soon so watch this space.

Does NELL have equalities and diversity groups? 

Yes, when you are a signed up member if you wish we will put you in touch with other members in the NELL Women, NELL Disabled Members, NELL LGBT+, NELL BAME and NELL Young Members groups in accordance with groups you identify with.

How does my Left/Socialist group affiliate to NELL?

Within the Organising Group there is a small sub-group of volunteers with responsibility to liaise with other Left groups across the North. If you email and provide contact details we will get back to you as soon as possible.